wimping out
Dec. 23rd, 2005 11:29 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
egypturnashi've gone back to QWERTY. The Dvorak layout is interesting, and I can see that it would be less fatigue-inducing than QWERTY is when touch-typing. But I haven't historically touch-typed. And trying to learn to do that is creating muscle strain - in my back, and more scarily in my right elbow.
Given that most of my typing is original, rather than dictation or duplication, speed is not that important. I could stand to be a bit faster, but I don't type that much slower than I compose and polish sentences. The two reasons to switch to Dvorak are speed and decreased strain compared to touch-typing QWERTY. Well, not touch-typing seems to be less stressful to my body than touch-typing is, period.
Other worries were lingering in the back of my head: being absolutely useless at typing anything for a month or so as I switch, and the loss of years of muscle memory for one-handed keystrokes. I rely on my left hand to switch tools with the keyboard when I do art on the computer; I've worked with my left hand on the keyboard and my right hand on the mouse or stylus since I got into Deluxe Paint on the Amiga. I've suffered some retraining, like going from Amiga to Mac tools, where 'undo' changed from 'u' to 'apple-z', but I'm sitting on top of twenty years of muscle memory I'm reluctant to slow down my art to relearn. Flash makes me swear when it loses the keyboard focus in certain conditions and I have to select a tool by clicking on it; I can't imagine retraining all the muscle associations for every tool in every program. I haven't touched AI during these past couple days of Dvorak for fear of this.
If I was already touch-typing, I think it might be worth it. But I don't. I don't want to train my little and index fingers to type, I don't want to try and create an environment that encourages proper typing posture. That's just not going to happen when your computing environment is a laptop on a bed. I'd like to have a desk again, and maybe I'll try Dvorak again when I do. There was some talk of me grabbing the one in Nick's room once he upgraded to his laptop, but it stayed there when Cyn moved in and is now weighed down with her system. I'm not sure I need a desk that big anyway - I just need space for computer, keyboard, tablet, and scanner, I don't need to accommodate a CRT's depth any more. There isn't room in here for a second large computer desk anyway.
So I'm back to QWERTY. I would have stuck with the Dvorak experiment longer, but pain is not something to ignore...
Given that most of my typing is original, rather than dictation or duplication, speed is not that important. I could stand to be a bit faster, but I don't type that much slower than I compose and polish sentences. The two reasons to switch to Dvorak are speed and decreased strain compared to touch-typing QWERTY. Well, not touch-typing seems to be less stressful to my body than touch-typing is, period.
Other worries were lingering in the back of my head: being absolutely useless at typing anything for a month or so as I switch, and the loss of years of muscle memory for one-handed keystrokes. I rely on my left hand to switch tools with the keyboard when I do art on the computer; I've worked with my left hand on the keyboard and my right hand on the mouse or stylus since I got into Deluxe Paint on the Amiga. I've suffered some retraining, like going from Amiga to Mac tools, where 'undo' changed from 'u' to 'apple-z', but I'm sitting on top of twenty years of muscle memory I'm reluctant to slow down my art to relearn. Flash makes me swear when it loses the keyboard focus in certain conditions and I have to select a tool by clicking on it; I can't imagine retraining all the muscle associations for every tool in every program. I haven't touched AI during these past couple days of Dvorak for fear of this.
If I was already touch-typing, I think it might be worth it. But I don't. I don't want to train my little and index fingers to type, I don't want to try and create an environment that encourages proper typing posture. That's just not going to happen when your computing environment is a laptop on a bed. I'd like to have a desk again, and maybe I'll try Dvorak again when I do. There was some talk of me grabbing the one in Nick's room once he upgraded to his laptop, but it stayed there when Cyn moved in and is now weighed down with her system. I'm not sure I need a desk that big anyway - I just need space for computer, keyboard, tablet, and scanner, I don't need to accommodate a CRT's depth any more. There isn't room in here for a second large computer desk anyway.
So I'm back to QWERTY. I would have stuck with the Dvorak experiment longer, but pain is not something to ignore...